Current Blog Article

Current Blog Article

SEO

How to Choose a B2B SEO Agency: 12 Questions, Red Flags and What a Good Proposal Includes.

Portrait of the Let's Nara blog author, a contributor covering B2B demand and lead generation.

Dwiky Juniarta

Featured illustration for How to Choose a B2B SEO Agency: 12 Questions, Red Flags and What a Good Proposal Includes
No headings found on page

I should say this up front: I run a B2B marketing agency, and SEO is one of the services we sell. So you have every reason to read an agency's guide to choosing an agency with some suspicion.

Here is how I have tried to make this one worth reading anyway. Every question below is one I would want a buyer to ask us. Every red flag is something I have seen in proposals that prospects showed me after a bad experience elsewhere. And the scorecard at the end works just as well for comparing us against other agencies as it does for anyone else.

The stakes are real. Choosing the wrong SEO agency in B2B rarely fails loudly. It fails slowly. Reports arrive every month, traffic rises a little, and a year later the sales team still cannot name a deal that came from search. By then you have lost twelve months of a channel that compounds.

This guide is for marketing leaders, sales leaders and founders at B2B companies who are about to hire an SEO agency, or who are wondering whether the one they have is the right one.

Quick answer: how to choose a B2B SEO agency.

The short version. Choose an agency that asks about your pipeline before it talks about keywords, has worked with companies that sell the way you sell, names the people who will do the work, and proposes a plan you can measure in qualified opportunities. Walk away from any agency that guarantees rankings.

The process in five steps.

  1. Decide whether you need an agency at all, or a hybrid with an in-house owner.

  2. Shortlist three to five agencies with relevant B2B experience.

  3. Ask each the same 12 questions and note how they answer, not only what they answer.

  4. Compare proposals against the same checklist.

  5. Score them on a weighted scorecard and check references before you sign.

The one red flag that matters most. Google's own guidance is direct: if an SEO guarantees that their changes will put you first in search results, find someone else.

Why choosing the right agency matters more in B2B.

Sourced stat block. What the research says about hiring providers.

Most B2B buyers are unhappy with who they chose. Forrester's State of Business Buying 2024 found that 81% of buyers expressed dissatisfaction with their chosen providers. That is across B2B purchases, not SEO specifically, but it shows how often the decision goes wrong.

Google says guarantees are a warning sign. In its guidance on hiring an SEO, Google advises interviewing potential SEOs, checking references, granting only read access to Search Console during an audit, and finding someone else if they guarantee first place in search results.

Results take time, so a bad choice is expensive. An often-cited Ahrefs study of two million pages found that only 5.7% reached the top 10 for at least one keyword within a year. Hire the wrong agency and you usually find out after that year has gone.

B2B adds three complications that most generic advice ignores.

Your buyers are few and specific. A good B2B agency knows that 50 visits from procurement managers in your industry can be worth more than 5,000 from students. An agency used to e-commerce or local businesses will chase volume by default.

Your sales cycle hides results. If deals take six months to close, a weak agency can look fine for a long time. You need an agency that reports on leading indicators honestly and connects SEO to your CRM, so you know early whether it is working.

Your content needs real expertise. A technical buyer will spot generic content in seconds. The agency has to be able to work with your subject-matter experts and turn what they know into pages that rank. If you want the background on how B2B SEO works before you hire, our complete guide to B2B SEO covers it.

Step 1. Decide whether you need an agency at all.

Not every company does. Google itself says that a small local business can probably do much of the work itself, starting with its SEO starter guide. For B2B companies, the question is usually less "agency or nothing" and more "who owns what".

You probably need an agency when you have no one in-house with SEO experience, you are planning a site redesign or migration (Google notes this is a great time to bring in an SEO, and the earlier the better), you need to move faster than your team's capacity allows, or you have tried in-house and stalled.

You may not need one when you have a capable in-house marketer with time to learn, a small and focused market, and patience. In that case, training and an occasional audit may be enough.

Many B2B companies end up with a hybrid. An internal owner who knows the business and the customers, and an agency for strategy, technical work and content production. This is often the best of both: the agency brings process and capacity, and the internal owner keeps it connected to sales.

Step 2. Build a shortlist of three to five agencies.

Fewer than three and you have nothing to compare. More than five and the evaluation becomes a project of its own.

Good places to start:

  • Referrals from peers in similar companies. Ask what the agency actually delivered, not just whether they liked them.

  • Review platforms such as Clutch, where you can filter by B2B focus and read verified client reviews.

  • Curated lists. We publish our own list of the best B2B SEO agencies, and a separate one for Jakarta. Treat any list, including ours, as a starting point rather than a verdict.

  • Who ranks for your category. An agency that ranks well for competitive B2B terms has at least shown it can do it for itself.

When you screen, look for agencies whose past clients sell the way you sell. A strong SaaS SEO agency is not automatically a strong agency for a construction supplier with a nine-month sales cycle, and the reverse is also true.

Step 3. Ask the same 12 questions to every agency.

Ask every agency the same questions, in the same order, and write down the answers. Pay attention to how they answer. A good agency will ask you questions back. Google's guidance makes the same point: your SEO should be interested in what makes your business unique, who your competitors are and how your customers find you.

Questions about your business and pipeline.

1. How will you tie SEO to qualified pipeline, not just traffic? A good answer mentions your CRM, organic-sourced and organic-influenced opportunities, and leading indicators for the first months. A weak answer is all about traffic, rankings and "visibility".

2. What do you need to know about our sales process before you start? A good agency will ask about deal size, sales cycle, buying committee and the questions prospects ask. If they have no questions, they are planning to run a template.

3. Which clients have you worked with that sell the way we do? Ask for examples with a similar sales motion, deal size or industry. Google suggests asking about experience in your industry and your country or city, too.

Questions about the people.

4. Who exactly will work on our account, and how much of their time will we get? Ask for names and roles. The people in the pitch are often not the people who do the work.

5. Who writes the content, and how do they work with our subject-matter experts? In B2B, the quality of the content depends on access to people who know the product or service. A good agency has a clear process for interviews, drafts and review.

Questions about the process.

6. What will you do in the first 90 days, and in what order? You want a sequence, not a menu. Good answers usually start with an audit, tracking and fixes to the pages that already convert (service and industry pages) before new blog content. Our 12-month B2B SEO roadmap shows what a sensible sequence looks like.

7. How do you decide which keywords get their own page? This question separates agencies that plan from agencies that publish. A good answer involves checking the actual search results, avoiding pages that compete with each other, and mapping each keyword to one page. A weak answer is "we will target the highest-volume keywords".

8. What will you change on our site, and will you show us every change and why? Google recommends asking whether the SEO will share all changes and explain the reasoning behind its recommendations. You should never be surprised by what is on your own website.

Questions about technical work and AI search.

9. How do you handle technical SEO, and who implements the fixes? Some agencies only recommend; others implement. Either can work, but you need to know which, and whether your developers have the capacity.

10. How do you approach AI search, and what is that advice based on? AI Overviews and AI assistants now shape how buyers research vendors. A good agency can explain how it tracks AI visibility and what it changes. Google's guidance suggests checking that any advice on optimising for AI features is in line with Google's official documentation, and asking whether the agency cites that documentation at all.

Questions about the contract.

11. What do we own if we part ways? Content, tracking setup, dashboards, keyword research and access to every account should belong to you. Get this in writing.

12. What results do you expect, by when, and how will we know early if it is not working? Google lists this question too: what results to expect, in what timeframe, and how success is measured. A good answer is specific about leading indicators in the first months and honest that pipeline takes longer. A weak answer is a ranking promise.

SEO agency red flags. When to walk away.

Any one of these should make you pause. Two or more, and I would keep looking.

Red flag

Why it matters

Guaranteed rankings or "page one in 30 days"

No one controls Google's rankings. Google's own guidance says to find someone else if an SEO guarantees first place.

No questions about your sales process

They are planning to run the same package for everyone.

The proposal is mostly a count of blog posts and backlinks

Volume is not a strategy. In B2B, a small number of the right pages usually beats a large number of average ones.

They want write access to Search Console or admin access before you sign

Google recommends read-only access during an audit.

Vague about who does the work

Senior people sell, junior people deliver, and you only find out after signing.

Reports focus on traffic and rankings only

You will get monthly charts that go up and a pipeline that does not.

"Proprietary" methods they cannot explain

Good SEO is not secret. If they cannot explain what they do and why, assume it is either generic or risky.

Long lock-in contracts with no exit terms

A confident agency does not need to trap you.

Cheap link packages

Bought links can damage your site. Ask exactly where links will come from.

No interest in your subject-matter experts

B2B content without real expertise rarely ranks or convinces.

And the green flags, briefly: they ask about your pipeline first, they push back on some of your ideas, they name the team, they show you the reasoning behind every recommendation, and they are honest about what will take time.

What a good B2B SEO proposal should include.

Most searches for "SEO proposal" come from agencies looking for templates. This section is the other side: what you, as the buyer, should expect to find in a proposal before you sign. Use it as a checklist.

Section

What good looks like

What to question

Discovery summary

Shows they understood your business, buyers, sales cycle and competitors

A generic introduction that could apply to anyone

Goals

Tied to qualified pipeline, with leading indicators for the first months

Only traffic or ranking targets

Initial findings

A few specific issues or opportunities they found on your site

No findings at all, or a long automated report

Scope and deliverables

What they will do each month, in what order, and what is out of scope

A list of activities with no sequence

First 90 days

A clear plan: audit, tracking, fixes to key pages, first decision-stage content

"Ongoing optimisation" with no detail

Team

Named people, their roles and time allocation

"A dedicated team" with no names

Reporting

What you will see, how often, and how it connects to your CRM

Traffic dashboards only

Your responsibilities

What they need from you: access, expert time, approvals, developer hours

Nothing, which usually means delays later

Pricing model

Clear fees, what is included, and what would cost extra

Hidden extras, vague "packages"

Contract terms

Notice period, ownership of work and accounts, how to exit

Long lock-in, unclear ownership

The "your responsibilities" row deserves more attention than it usually gets. Many SEO engagements stall not because the agency fails but because the client cannot give expert time or developer hours. A good proposal says so up front.

How much does it cost to hire a B2B SEO agency?

It varies widely with scope, market and seniority, so be wary of any single number. What you can compare is the pricing model:

  • Monthly retainer. The most common model. A fixed monthly fee for an agreed scope. Good for ongoing programs where strategy, content and technical work run together.

  • Project fee. A fixed price for a defined piece of work: an audit, a migration, a set of service pages. Good when you have a clear, bounded need or want to test an agency before a longer commitment.

  • Hourly or consulting. Useful for advisory work when your team does the implementation.

  • Performance-based. Fees tied to results. Be careful: if the results are rankings or traffic, the incentive can push the agency toward vanity metrics rather than pipeline.

When you compare proposals, compare the work and the team, not just the fee. A cheaper proposal that leaves out content production or technical implementation is not cheaper if you have to add those later.

A scorecard to compare agencies.

Score each agency from 1 to 5 on each criterion, multiply by the weight, and add the totals. Agree the weights with your team before you see the proposals, so the scoring is not shaped by the best presentation.

Criterion

Weight

Agency A

Agency B

Agency C

Understanding of our business and pipeline

20%




Relevant experience (similar sales motion, industry or market)

15%




Quality of the first 90-day plan

15%




The named team and their time

15%




Content quality and access to our experts

10%




Technical and AI search capability

10%




Reporting connected to our CRM

10%




Contract terms, ownership and price

5%




Total

100%




Then check references. Google suggests asking past clients whether the SEO provided a useful service, was easy to work with and produced positive results. I would add one question: "What would you do differently if you hired them again?"

Local or international agency? A note for Southeast Asia.

If you sell in Indonesia or across Southeast Asia, decide what you need the agency to know.

A local agency usually understands the market, the language mix and the buyers better. Many B2B buyers here search in English for technical topics and in Bahasa Indonesia for local services, and the right balance depends on your industry. A local agency is also easier to meet and often better at local proof: regional case studies, local publications and partners.

An international agency may bring deeper specialist experience, especially if you sell into the US or Europe. If you choose one, ask Google's question directly: what is your experience in our country, and with international sites?

There is no right answer, only the one that matches where your buyers are.

What to expect in the first 90 days after you sign.

A good start looks like this, roughly in this order:

  1. Weeks 1 to 2. Kick-off, access to your accounts, interviews with sales and subject-matter experts, agreement on goals and leading indicators.

  2. Weeks 3 to 6. Technical and content audit, tracking connected to your CRM, a keyword map checked against the actual search results.

  3. Weeks 7 to 12. Fixes to critical technical issues, rebuilt service and industry pages, and the first decision-stage content.

By day 90 you should not expect much pipeline yet. You should expect a clear plan, visible fixes, tracking that works and early signs in Search Console. If you are 90 days in and still waiting for an audit, raise it.

How Let's Nara answers these questions.

Since I have asked you to put these 12 questions to every agency, here is how we answer the most important ones, briefly.

  • Pipeline first. Before keyword research, we ask for your deal size, sales cycle, win rate and the questions prospects ask on calls.

  • One page per search need. We check the search results for every planned keyword before assigning it, so your pages do not compete with each other. We do this on our own site too.

  • Service pages before the blog. The first 90 days focus on the pages that already convert, plus tracking.

  • You own everything. Content, tracking, dashboards and research belong to you.

  • No ranking guarantees. We agree leading indicators for the first months and report honestly against them.

We work with B2B companies in tech, industrial manufacturing and construction, from startups to enterprise, from our base in Jakarta. If you would like to put these questions to us, our B2B SEO services page explains how an engagement works, and the B2B SEO Blogging Playbook shows the framework we use, whether you hire us or not.

Frequently asked questions.

How do I pick an SEO agency?

Shortlist three to five agencies with experience in companies like yours, ask each the same set of questions, compare their proposals against the same checklist and score them on a weighted scorecard. Check references before signing. In B2B, prioritise agencies that ask about your pipeline and sales process before they talk about keywords.

What questions should I ask an SEO agency?

The most important are: how they will tie SEO to qualified pipeline, who exactly will do the work, what they will do in the first 90 days, how they decide which keywords get their own page, what you own if you part ways, and what results to expect by when. The 12 questions in this guide cover the rest.

What are the red flags when hiring an SEO agency?

Guaranteed rankings, no questions about your business, proposals built on post and link counts, requests for write access before you sign, vague team details, traffic-only reporting, unexplained "proprietary" methods, long lock-in contracts and cheap link packages.

What should a B2B SEO proposal include?

A discovery summary, goals tied to pipeline, initial findings, scope and deliverables in sequence, a first 90-day plan, the named team, reporting, your responsibilities, a clear pricing model and contract terms covering ownership and exit.

Should a B2B company use an SEO agency or hire in-house?

It depends on your capacity, budget and timeline. In-house staff know your business best; agencies bring process, specialist skills and capacity. Many B2B companies use a hybrid, with an internal owner working alongside an agency.

How long before an SEO agency shows results?

Expect visible progress in the first 90 days (fixes, tracking, early signs in Search Console), first organic enquiries in months four to six, and pipeline you can attribute with confidence between months six and twelve, depending on your sales cycle.

The bottom line. Hire the agency that asks the best questions.

The best predictor of a good B2B SEO agency is not the pitch deck. It is the questions the agency asks you. An agency that wants to understand your buyers, your sales cycle and your experts before it talks about keywords is already thinking about pipeline. An agency that leads with rankings and post counts is thinking about its package.

Ask every agency the same 12 questions, compare proposals against the same checklist, walk away from guarantees, and score them before you see the price. That process will not make the decision for you, but it will make the wrong decision much less likely.

If you want to put these questions to us, get in touch.

Dwiky Juniarta, Founder, Let's Nara

Get discovery and strategy phase for free for your first collaboration by sending your queries to us.

๐Ÿ“Jakarta, Indonesia

โ˜Ž๏ธ (+62) 813 2160 040

Get discovery and strategy phase for free for your first collaboration by sending your queries to us.

Jakarta, Indonesia